May 16,
2005
By Galen
Gruman, editorial director, IT Wireless
A free newsletter to all IT Wireless
subscribers.
THIS ISSUE'S SPONSOR: GLOBAL KNOWLEDGE
IN THIS ISSUE:
From our sponsor
Take the "Global Knowledge Challenge"! Our IT Expert Challenge, a 20-question exam designed by
industry experts, will challenge your grasp on a variety of IT skills. Be one of
the first 500 participates to beat the Challenge, and you could receive a free
T-Shirt. Go on, see how bright you are! Click here to take the
Challenge now.
FEATURE
STORY
Time Warner Center Goes for a Unified
Infrastructure
The new Time Warner Center high-rise near Manhattan's Central Park is a
showplace property for residents and businesses. It was also an opportunity to
design wireless communications from the ground up, rather than retrofit an
existing structure by placing access points in carefully determined locations to
ensure appropriate coverage without interference, all while dealing with
physical challenges such as routing cables to each access point.
Rather than use the traditional access-point approach, the Time Warner Center
used InnerWireless's multifrequency antennas, which are embedded throughout the
building's ceilings. Instead of being a series of access points cabled together,
the InnerWireless approach uses one large antenna grid, so signals radiate and
are received at all points of the cable, rather than just at discrete access
points. Each antenna grid connects to an access point to handle the network
functions, such as access control, signal management, and handoff to the rest of
the network.
Shaped like an H and embedded in the ceilings, the antenna for each
floor connects to one access point for that floor, rather than having multiple
antennas daisy-chained on each floor. (The antenna shape will vary based on the
building's design.) For example, in the Mandarin Oriental hotel that occupies
about 20% of the Time Warner Center, there are just 26 access points to manage
compared to the 300 or so that would have been required with the traditional
approach, says Dave Heckaman, who leads IT for the Mandarin Oriental Hotel. To
add capacity, "you just add more access points to the network closet" — using
different channels, of course — Heckaman says. The concept is similar to a wired
network, where the router is in a network closet and the cable carries the
signal to the users' devices throughout the floor.
At the Time Warner Center, the wireless infrastructure supports several
communications systems, some wireless and some wired: 802.11b wireless, cellular
networks, paging networks, closed-circuit TV (for security staff), building
control systems, and two-way Fire Dept. communications. By using multifrequency
antennas, the InnerWireless infrastructure can support all these systems with
one common antenna grid. The center has about 2.5 million square feet, with 11
nodes to cover various sections of the building. (Each section encompasses
500,000 to 750,000 square feet and connects to other nodes via intertrunk
connections.)
 |
|
Although the infrastructure is common to all tenants and
building management, "you still layer in your intranet security as you
would have in any wireless network, such as with virtual LANs," Heckaman
says. Thus some services, such as voice over IP, can be made available
throughout the building, while others such as local wireless LANs can be
segmented off. The system as a whole is managed by a building data
provider, essentially an outsourced network administrator for the building
who manages tenant segments as well as the entire building network. "You
could instead have different organizations providing management if you
wanted," Heckaman notes, as long as they cooperate with each
other.
While the InnerWireless approach is well-suited for new
buildings or significantly reconstructed buildings that let the antenna
grids be installed, it doesn't work as well in existing structures, since
the cost of tearing apart the ceilings would be prohibitive. In existing
structures, the traditional daisy-chaining of access points usually makes
more sense, an InnerWireless spokesman acknowledges.
[After this story was published, the spokesman cited in
the story claimed he made no such comment, and several InnerWireless PR
and marketing staff disputed this last point, saying that the company's
approach is less expensive because they offer support for more than just
802.11: "The cost of the full-service InnerWireless infrastructure
is spread over a full range of services. In multiple access point deployments,
each installation must bear the full cost. It is less expensive to deploy
our Wireless Utility solution in existing buildings than to serve the
same set of needs with traditional multiple deployment approaches,"
wrote marketing director Tom Eagle in an email. But that lower-cost claim
assumes that an organization is installing multiple services as was done
at the Time Warner Center. Eagle and InnerWireless's PR representatives
did not respond to several requests for details on installation costs
for its systems versus traditional 802.11 installation costs in existing
structures. Ed.]
|
Got deployment experience and lessons
to share? Let us know at news@it-wireless.com.
THIS ISSUE'S
SPONSOR: GLOBAL KNOWLEDGE
For advertising information, contact
Manny Sawit at (510) 583-0855 or msawit@it-wireless.com
From IT
Wireless
Tell a Friend!
Forward them this newsletter
Get Expert Information on Wireless
Networking
As an IT professional, you know
that wireless technologies such as 802.11 promise to provide significant
benefits to your organization. Before you go full steam ahead, you need answers
to your critical concerns about wireless LANs. Questions concerning security,
compatibility and best practices, to name just a few. The IT Wireless
Insider and IT Wireless Market Scan email newsletters are now here
to help you figure it all out.
Get your FREE
subscription to the email IT Wireless newsletters today!
Copyright © 2005
EmergeMedia Inc. All rights reserved. This email newsletter may be forwarded in
whole via email. Other copying, whether in whole or in part, via electronic or
print means, is prohibited without prior written permission of EmergeMedia.
EmergeMedia Inc., 28750 Fox Hollow Dr., Hayward, CA 94542.
Subscription and
account changes:
This newsletter is sent to all subscribers to the
IT Wireless newsletters; subscribers provided their email address at
the time they requested the publication at our Web site and received a
confirmation of their subscription at that time. Click here to change subscription information, change third-party opt-in
settings, or cancel your subscription.